Natural Toothpaste vs Regular Toothpaste
You’re not alone if you’re curious about the differences between natural toothpaste vs regular toothpaste. More and more people are rethinking what they put on their toothbrushes as they become aware of what’s in all those drugstore formulas.
But is natural toothpaste as effective as regular toothpaste? You don’t want to go natural if it means compromising on your oral health. We’re going to help you narrow it down and make the right decision.
If you’re serious about elevating your oral hygiene, though, upgrade to our gel toothpaste at LIVFRESH. It’s powered by a patented ingredient known as activated edathamil, which fights plaque at the molecular level, improves gum health, and may even help remineralize teeth.
The best part? It contains 100% edible ingredients. No antimicrobials, abrasives, parabens, SLS, triclosan, or other nasty stuff. Find out firsthand why LIVFRESH is the best toothpaste for receding gums and the best toothpaste to remove plaque and tartar!
Key Takeaways
- Regular toothpaste uses foaming agents, abrasives, dyes, and flavor additives that clean the tooth surface but can cause problems.
- Natural toothpaste skips many of those in favor of gentler ingredients meant for daily, long-term use.
- The problem is that plenty of “natural” formulas sound good on the label but don’t do much for plaque or gum health.
- Effectiveness still comes down to how well a toothpaste disrupts plaque - not how earthy the packaging looks.
- LIVFRESH uses activated edathamil to break plaque’s grip on teeth, delivering measurable results without harsh or unnecessary ingredients.
What is in Regular Toothpaste?
Understanding the difference between natural toothpaste vs regular toothpaste starts with getting a little more specific about what is in the typical toothpaste you have access to at drugstores.
When we talk about these types of toothpastes, we’re referring to brands like Crest, Colgate, and even Sensodyne, among many others. They all rely on really similar formulas that clean teeth, using ingredients such as:
- Fluoride (sodium/stannous fluoride): Cavity protection, but can be irritating for people with sensitive mouths (especially in stronger formulas).
- Abrasives (hydrated silica, calcium carbonate): Scrubs away surface stains, but overuse can be really rough on enamel and exposed gums.
- SLS (sodium lauryl sulfate): The foaming agent that creates that “lathered” feel, but it’s a common trigger for mouth irritation and can make canker sores worse.
- Artificial flavors and sweeteners: Added for taste but have zero oral health benefits and plenty of health concerns.
- Synthetic dyes: Used solely for looks, with no functional purpose in cleaning teeth.
- Preservatives and stabilizers: Keep texture consistent, but again, no benefits and a laundry list of potential concerns.
The worst part? These types of formulas do very little to actually improve your oral health aside from cavity prevention. They don’t make as much of a dent on plaque and tartar buildup as you’d hope. There’s little gum health benefit, either. So, how does natural toothpaste compare?
What is in Natural Toothpaste?
Let’s get a bit more specific about what makes a toothpaste “natural.” Most people associate it with plant-based formulas, which rely on coconut oil, aloe vera, tea tree oil, or herbal extracts for mild antibacterial support and soothing.
Or, you could be looking for something that just uses mineral-based cleaners. Think calcium carbonate, baking soda, or clay. There are also people who define natural toothpastes as those free from fluoride, which instead utilize hydroxyapatite.
At any rate, a natural toothpaste should omit common triggers like SLS and strong synthetic flavoring agents. The shorter the ingredient list, the better. Everything in the formula should be safe and edible for all ages. LIVFRESH checks that box.
Our plaque removal toothpaste is backed by 40 patents and 26 research studies showing just how much better it is than your average formula. It can:
- Remove up to 250% more plaque
- Improve gum health by 190% more
- May even remineralize teeth
It’s all thanks to activated edathamil, which alters the surface charge of teeth and disrupts the bond plaque forms, so it’s easy to brush and rinse away. It also prevents new plaque from forming. That’s why thousands of dental professionals recommend it, and even more customers have made the switch without looking back.
Natural Toothpaste vs Regular Toothpaste: Key Differences to Consider
Still on the fence about natural toothpaste vs regular toothpaste? The differences start with ingredients, but extend to the risk profile and potential benefits of a formula. Here’s a closer look at natural toothpaste vs regular toothpaste side-by-side.
Key Ingredients
Regular toothpaste from major drugstore brands might have slightly different branding, but you’ll see more or less the same thing when you “look under the hood.” They all rely on synthetic foaming agents, artificial dyes, and strong flavor systems alongside fluoride.
Sure, these blends clean teeth - at least, on the surface level. But at what cost? They may cause irritation if you have sensitivity. They don’t work as deeply as they should, either.
That’s why natural toothpastes usually skip SLS, artificial coloring, and heavy flavoring. Many rely on minerals, plant-derived cleansers, or newer biofilm-disrupting ingredients rather than detergents.
Cavity Protection
This is where traditional toothpaste does have a place. Most brands rely on fluoride as the primary defense against cavities. It’s effective, especially if you’re prone to decay. But in looking at fluoride vs fluoride-free toothpaste, it’s clear you don’t have to rely on this ingredient.
Natural toothpastes can fight cavities too, but they go about it differently. Some use hydroxyapatite, and some rely on plaque control as the first line of defense since cavities start with buildup, not sugar alone.
Plaque and Gum Health
The gap between natural toothpaste vs regular toothpaste becomes a lot more noticeable in looking at how each addresses plaque buildup and gum health.
Plaque is the root of all evil in oral health. It’s what leads to tartar buildup, which can really wreak havoc on teeth and gums. The best formulas address it head-on and treat it as the enemy it is.
The problem is, MOST regular toothpastes don’t do a very good job of this. They clean the surface of the tooth but don’t do much to loosen plaque once it bonds to enamel. That’s why buildup can return fast even if you brush consistently.
On the other hand, formulas like LIVFRESH fight plaque through molecular chemistry instead of relying solely on manual scrubbing. They disrupt the bond plaque forms on your teeth so it can be brushed and rinsed away effortlessly.
Breath Freshening
You want fresh breath, but regular toothpaste brands are notorious for overloading their formulas with strong mint oils and synthetic cooling agents for an intense burst of freshness. It works fast, but fades just as quickly.
In contrast, natural toothpastes keep things subtle and softer. Breath stays neutral for longer because odor-causing compounds aren’t being masked - they’re reduced at the source.
Teeth Whitening
A lot of regular toothpastes are marketed as whitening formulas, because let’s be honest - we all want shinier teeth. The thing is, though, most brands use abrasives or peroxide-adjacent ingredients to lift stains. These can work, but overuse may irritate enamel or gum tissue.
Natural options don’t market themselves as “whitening,” but that doesn’t mean it isn’t happening slowly but surely over time. They gradually reduce plaque and surface film instead of scrubbing aggressively. The change is slower, but easier on teeth long term.
Enamel Safety and Abrasion
Most mainstream formulas sit pretty high on the abrasion scale, especially whitening formulas. That matters if you brush hard or already have enamel wear. It can slowly but surely lead to sensitivity and recession.
Natural toothpaste usually uses gentler polishing agents or non-abrasive technology. The goal is to do the job at hand without causing more harm than good.
The Brushing Experience
Even the brushing experience is a little different when comparing natural toothpaste vs regular toothpaste.
You’ll get a really thick foaming effect with mainstream brands because of that SLS content. It feels familiar, but it’s more of a marketing gimmick than anything. More foam doesn’t necessarily translate to better cleaning. There is a sharper, mintier burn as well.
But natural toothpaste is the total opposite. It feels smoother, lighter, and less aggressive. Yet, it cleans your teeth just as well - if not better - than regular toothpaste.
Is Natural Toothpaste as Effective as Regular Toothpaste?
The short answer is it absolutely can be, as long as the formula goes beyond herbs and flavor alone. Not all natural toothpastes are built the same, and many fall short when it comes to real plaque control.
There’s no point in going with a “natural” toothpaste that doesn’t really improve your oral hygiene, just for the sake of saying you’re using a natural formula. That’s why LIVFRESH is the smartest upgrade you can make in your oral care ritual.
Our formula avoids harsh additives while using activated edathamil, a patented ingredient shown to loosen plaque from enamel rather than scrubbing over it. Clinical testing shows stronger plaque removal and better gum health results than conventional toothpaste, without relying on irritation or heavy abrasion. Here’s why more and more dentists are recommending it:
- Available in foaming or non-foaming options
- Fresh, natural flavor
- Stops bad breath at the source
- Prevents tartar buildup
- Improves gum health
- May remineralize teeth
- Has zero antimicrobials or parabens
- Gluten-free, sugar-free, triclosan-free, and SLS-free
- Safe for all ages
- Crafted in the USA
Don’t settle for basic drugstore brands or overhyped natural toothpastes. Get the best care for your teeth and gums at LIVFRESH today. Order now risk-free!
“My bad breath is gone 😄” - Natalia
“The toothpaste gets my teeth really, really clean. The toothpaste is not stinky - that big, artificial mint scent - and I like the low foam presentation.” - Avery
“It's ten times better than anything you can buy at the store.” - Lourenda
Final Words on Natural Toothpaste vs Regular Toothpaste
The real difference that matters in looking at natural toothpaste vs regular toothpaste is how they treat your teeth and gums over time. Traditional options get the job done, but many rely on harsher ingredients that don’t work well for everyone.
On the other hand, natural toothpastes have cleaner formulas - but do they clean your teeth as well as they should? Or, do they just hook you in with their marketing? That’s the uncertainty with so many brands that are overpromising and underdelivering.
LIVFRESH is different. It protects you from the stuff you don’t want in your mouth while actually improving your oral hygiene, with clinical studies to back it up.
You can learn more about Crest vs Colgate or Toms vs Hello toothpaste in our blog if you’re curious about the different formulas on the market. But whether you’re looking for a Sensodyne alternative or something better than the other basic drugstore brands, your search ends here.
Make the switch and see how different your daily brushing routine can feel with LIVFRESH!
