David's vs Ollie Toothpaste (vs LIVFRESH)
You’re not alone if you’re pondering David's vs Ollie toothpaste. These two clean-ingredient brands both use nano-hydroxyapatite and avoid the synthetic fillers most mass-market tubes are packed with.
They’re more similar than they are different. That’s why it can be tough to narrow it down between Ollie vs David’s toothpaste. They’re not bad for people trying to get away from Colgate and Crest without sacrificing too much on performance. They’re not going to do anything dramatic for your oral health, though.
That’s why we’re going to reframe this comparison to include LIVFRESH. Two toothpaste formulas, both centered around Activated Edathamil. This ingredient is protected by 40 patents and backed by 40 clinical studies showing superior performance for plaque removal, bleeding gums, and more. See why thousands of dentists recommend LIVFRESH gel toothpaste today.
Quick Comparison of LIVFRESH vs David's vs Ollie Toothpaste
|
|
LIVFRESH |
David's |
Ollie |
|
Active Technology |
Patented Activated Edathamil |
Baking Soda + Hydrated Silica (original) / nHAp (Hydroxi line) |
10% Nano-Hydroxyapatite |
|
Fluoride Option |
Yes (Gum Protect+) |
No |
Yes (Fresh Mint) |
|
Published Clinical Studies |
40 |
None |
None |
|
Plaque Removal |
250% better (original) / 160% better (Gum Protect+) |
Antiplaque (no clinical figure) |
No specific claim |
|
Gum Health |
190% improvement (original) / 400% less bleeding (Gum Protect+) |
Mouth & Gum Detox (no clinical figure) |
No specific claim |
|
Abrasives |
None |
Yes (calcium carbonate, hydrated silica) |
Yes (calcium carbonate, hydrated silica) |
|
SLS-Free |
Yes |
Yes |
Yes |
|
Price |
$29.99 |
$10.95 (Hydroxi, 4oz) |
$16.95 (4oz) |
Pros and Cons of David's Toothpaste
David's makes toothpaste from clean, naturally derived ingredients in recyclable aluminum tubes. The original formula cleans through abrasive action, relying on baking soda and hydrated silica. The newer Hydroxi line uses nano-hydroxyapatite for enamel support.
Everything is EWG Verified, cruelty-free, and made in the USA. But a clean label only does so much. We think oral health outcomes matter more than anything else.
Pros
- Wide flavor range - peppermint, spearmint, charcoal, herbal citrus, and a strawberry watermelon kids option
- EWG Verified across the lineup
- Recyclable aluminum tubes with food-grade liners
- Most affordable of the three at $10.95 for the Hydroxi (4oz)
- Sensitive + Whitening variant with potassium chloride for nerve sensitivity
Cons
- Abrasive cleaning (calcium carbonate, hydrated silica) wears enamel over time.
- No published clinical studies backing the brand's performance claims
- nHAp concentration not disclosed on the Hydroxi line
- No fluoride option for those who want it
Pros and Cons of Ollie Toothpaste
Ollie’s toothpaste is powered by 10% nano-hydroxyapatite. Research shows that’s the optimal concentration for enamel remineralization. The rest of the formula is minimal; just 11 ingredients per tube.
Pros
- 10% nHAp at the clinically studied concentration (and they actually disclose it)
- Only 11 clean ingredients per formula
- Both fluoride-free and fluoride options available
- Strong customer reviews (4.6/5 from 3,170+ ratings)
- Fresh Mint formula adds potassium nitrate for sensitivity relief
- 10% of profits go to oral care access programs
Cons
- More expensive than David's at $16.95 for 4oz
- No published clinical studies specific to the Ollie formula
- nHAp remineralization takes weeks to months before you notice changes
- Smaller tube than David's (4oz vs 5.25oz on the original line)
- Doesn’t appear to do much for plaque removal/prevention or gum health
How Does LIVFRESH Toothpaste Compare to David's and Ollie?
We know you came here curious about David's vs Ollie toothpaste, and both deliver what they promise: cleaner ingredients and nHAp-based enamel support. The truth is, though, they fall short in the same place most toothpastes do.
Neither brand has clinical data published in peer-reviewed journals. They weren’t formulated to directly address gum health at the source or prevent plaque from returning. That's what separates LIVFRESH from the Ollie vs David’s toothpaste conversation.
How Does Activated Edathamil Work?
Patented Activated Edathamil does something really unique - it dissolves the molecular bond between plaque and your teeth. Then it leaves behind a negative electrical charge on the tooth surface that actively repels new bacteria from attaching.
The longer you use LIVFRESH, the more that barrier builds. Plaque levels keep dropping, and gum health slowly but surely begins to improve. You may notice less bleeding, or perhaps you just feel as if your teeth are cleaner.
The results speak for themselves - and as the only brand in this comparison with real clinical data to back up these claims, that’s worth noting.
Two Formulas For Different Oral Health Goals
The original fluoride-free plaque removal toothpaste uses Activated Edathamil alone. It removes plaque 250% better than leading brands while helping improve gum health by 190%. No abrasives, detergents, or any other harsh ingredients you want to steer clear of.
The gum protection toothpaste (Gum Protect+) pairs Activated Edathamil with Stannous Fluoride to reduce gum bleeding and swelling 400% better than a leading ADA-approved brand. It also remineralizes teeth better than nano-hydroxyapatite in clinical testing.
That’s why it’s worth comparing alongside David's vs Ollie toothpaste. Yes, LIVFRESH costs more than both. But you get what you pay for. Performance backed by clinical studies. Your oral health is something worth investing in, don’t you think?
Should You Brush With LIVFRESH, David's, or Ollie Toothpaste?
Choosing between LIVFRESH vs David's vs Ollie toothpaste really depends on what your mouth needs most. Here's how each brand stacks up across the oral health goals that actually matter.
Enamel Repair
David's Hydroxi and Ollie both rely on nano-hydroxyapatite to fill in microscopic enamel damage over time. Ollie is more transparent about concentration (10%), so it has the edge over David’s in our book.
However, LIVFRESH Gum Protect+ works differently. Clinical data shows it remineralizes better than nHAp while also strengthening and protecting enamel through the Stannous Fluoride component. It’s the best enamel repair toothpaste on the market right now.
Gum Protection
This is where the Ollie vs David's toothpaste comparison hits a wall. Neither brand makes specific, clinically backed gum health claims. David's mentions “gum detox” on the label but doesn’t tell you what that means.
In contrast, LIVFRESH was built specifically to be the best toothpaste for bleeding gums and gum health overall. Published results show 190% gum health improvement (original formula) and 400% reduction in bleeding and swelling (Gum Protect+). Less bleeding in as little as 4 weeks.
Plaque Removal
David's and Ollie both rely on abrasive action to physically remove plaque, which is honestly the root of all evil in oral health. The problem is, you’re only removing plaque where your bristles actually reach. And you’re only removing plaque to the extent that your technique allows.
On the other hand, LIVFRESH removes plaque 250% better (original) and 160% better (Gum Protect+) than leading brands, proven in double-blind studies. That’s because Activated Edathamil doesn't just scrub plaque off. It prevents new plaque from forming in the first place. You’re able to actually get ahead of the issue rather than constantly playing catch up.
Teeth Whitening
Maybe you care more about the cosmetic side of things than anything else. David's uses hydrated silica as the whitening agent and does make whitening claims, so it could be the best fit here. Ollie says nHAp is a natural whitener since smoother enamel reflects more light. We think that’s a stretch, though.
LIVFRESH isn't formulated as a whitening toothpaste. It’s less about vanity, more about measurable oral health outcomes. However, removing way more plaque and buildup does reveal a naturally cleaner surface. The results speak for themselves after a few weeks of use.
If you are interested in whitening your teeth, check out LIVFRESH Whitening Strips. They’re a unique combination of traditional whitening with our unique coconut oil pulling technology. Get 8 shades of whitening within 14 days without sensitivity!
Breath Freshening
All three brands use peppermint oil for flavor. You get a little more variety with David's spearmint, wintergreen, and herbal citrus options. Ollie keeps it simple with two mint flavors.
LIVFRESH targets the root cause of bad breath by removing the bacteria and biofilm responsible for it, instead of trying to cover odor with stronger flavoring. That’s really the key takeaway from this LIVFRESH vs David’s vs Ollie toothpaste comparison. Most toothpastes are reactive. LIVFRESH is proactive.
The Bottom Line on Ollie vs David's Toothpaste
Hopefully this Ollie vs David's toothpaste conversation left you feeling confident in which is right for you - if either. David's is cheaper and offers more flavors. Ollie is more transparent about nHAp concentration.
Both are legitimate upgrades from mass-market tubes like those Colgate vs Crest make. Still, neither David's nor Ollie can point to published, peer-reviewed clinical data. LIVFRESH can. It’s the better Ollie and David’s toothpaste alternative.
So really, the only decision to make today is whether you want the original LIVFRESH formula or the Gum Protect+ variation. Learn more about the science behind LIVFRESH today.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Ollie toothpaste a good toothpaste?
Yes, for enamel remineralization specifically. 10% nHAp at the right concentration with only 11 ingredients. It won't address gum health, though, and it’s hard to call it the best toothpaste for cavities either.
Is David's a good toothpaste brand?
It’s not bad if you want EWG Verified ingredients, recyclable packaging, and a wide flavor selection at a reasonable price. But will it move the needle on your oral health? Probably not. See our Boka vs David's toothpaste breakdown for more info.
Why don't dentists recommend hydroxyapatite?
Plenty do, especially outside the US. Japan approved nHAp as an anti-cavity agent back in 1993. Fluoride still has decades more clinical backing in the US, though, so most dentists prefer it.
What makes LIVFRESH so different from other toothpastes?
Patented Activated Edathamil. Instead of scrubbing with abrasives or filling cracks with minerals, it dissolves the bond between plaque and your teeth at a molecular level. Then it creates a barrier that stops new plaque from sticking. It’s also a gel rather than a paste. Learn what that means in our toothpaste gel vs paste breakdown.
