People Are Reading Now

David’s Toothpaste Alternative

Author

Michael Hansford

Published

September 15, 2025

Fewer and fewer people are settling for drugstore toothpaste formulas. You have so many options at your disposal these days, including David’s Toothpaste - a popular fluoride-free formula.

But once you take a closer look at what’s on the market, brushing your teeth with David’s toothpaste feels like settling. The good news is a better David’s toothpaste alternative is just a few clicks away.

We’ll help you weigh the top choices on the market, like RiseWell, Boka, Hello, and more. The #1 alternative to David’s toothpaste, though, is our gel toothpaste here at LIVFRESH. It features a patented ingredient known as Activated Edathamil that can help:

Remove plaque up to 250% better
Improve gum health by 190% more
Remineralize teeth similar to fluoride toothpaste

It’s backed by 26 clinical studies and recommended by thousands of dentists worldwide. You can try it risk-free for 30 days. Get the #1 plaque removal toothpaste at LIVFRESH today!

“I have finished my first order. Healthier gums and teeth. My hygienist asked me which toothpaste brand I am using on my last visit. I was happy to share it. Worth every penny.” - Hilal

“This toothpaste is magical how it gets the plaque of my teeth. Teeth feel so smooth after.” - James

“Until you try this gel, you can’t appreciate the end result.. I’m saying after your second tube, you will be hooked.” - RW

Brand	Primary Active	Key Oral Health Benefits	Clean Label Highlights	Clinical Backing / Patents
LIVFRESH	Activated Edathamil (patented)	Clinically shown to reduce plaque, support gum health, support tooth remineralization, smooth enamel for easier cleaning	No fluoride, no SLS, no triclosan, naturally derived foaming option	Backed by 26 clinical studies; 40 patents, 3,000 dentist recommendations
RiseWell	Hydroxyapatite (non-nano)	Helps strengthen enamel, reduce sensitivity, supports natural whitening	Fluoride-free, SLS-free, no artificial flavors or dyes	Supported by general research on hydroxyapatite; no brand-specific patents or published clinical trials
Boka	Nano-Hydroxyapatite	Remineralizes enamel, helps sensitivity, everyday cavity support	Fluoride-free, SLS-free, no peroxide or artificial dyes	Relies on decades of hydroxyapatite studies; no unique clinical publications on Boka’s specific formula
Tom’s of Maine	Hydrated Silica (abrasive)	Surface stain removal, basic plaque and tartar control	Fluoride-free in antiplaque formula, no artificial flavors or dyes	No proprietary clinical research; supported mainly by ADA acceptance of certain fluoride versions
Hello	Mineral blend + Zinc Citrate	Surface stain removal, tartar control, fresh breath with tea tree + coconut oil	Fluoride-free, SLS-free, no peroxide, no artificial sweeteners	No peer-reviewed clinical studies or patents tied directly to Hello’s toothpaste

Why is David’s Toothpaste Good?

David’s Toothpaste is a natural, eco-conscious choice that doesn’t use fluoride. Instead, it relies on hydrated silica and calcium carbonate as mild abrasives to clean and polish teeth.

The formula also has xylitol, a plant-derived sweetener known to reduce cavity-causing bacteria, along with ingredients like sodium cocoyl glutamate (a gentler alternative to SLS), glycerin for texture, and peppermint oil for flavor. It’s a clean toothpaste.

David’s toothpaste is vegan and free from common additives like SLS, artificial sweeteners, flavors, colors, or preservatives. It’s marketed toward those who want a minimalist ingredient list with no “mystery chemicals.”

Another thing that’s really unique is it comes in an aluminum tube with a metal key, which is recyclable. This helps you squeeze out every last drop and avoid putting more plastic into landfills.

The toothpaste is both refreshing and natural without the overwhelming burn or foamy lather found in conventional pastes. The crisp mint oil gives you that familiar sensation from brushing, and there’s no harsh detergents - a plus for people who struggle with sensitivity.

Ingredients are USA-sourced whenever possible, and David’s clearly lists the function of each component so you don’t have to wonder what you’re putting in your mouth (and why). It checks a lot of boxes - so why are people looking for a David’s toothpaste alternative?

Why More People Are Looking For an Alternative to David’s Toothpaste

Don’t get us wrong, there’s a lot to love about this toothpaste compared to the mainstream options at your local drug store. But the simple fact of the matter is it may fall short in performance compared to other solutions on the market.

Because it does not contain fluoride or clinically proven alternatives like hydroxyapatite or activated edathamil, it offers little in terms of enamel remineralization or cavity prevention. In other words, it cleans well but doesn’t actively protect or strengthen teeth.

Texture is another sticking point for some people, according to reviews at least. The paste can feel grittier and drier compared to smoother gels, which turns off people who prefer a creamier or more foamy brushing experience.

The truth is, you deserve more from a toothpaste. What you choose to brush your teeth with can make or break your oral hygiene. From improving gum health to preventing cavities, freshening your breath, and helping you get cleaner teeth, we’ll unveil the top alternatives below.

What’s the Best David’s Toothpaste Alternative?

If you love the clean-label approach of David’s but want a toothpaste that goes beyond surface cleaning, there are options designed to actively support long-term oral health. But the best David’s toothpaste alternative is right here at LIVFRESH.

LIVFRESH Toothpaste

What sets LIVFRESH apart is its patented formulation with activated edathamil, an ingredient backed by 26 published clinical studies. The formula itself has 40 different patents, and it’s easy to see what makes the toothpaste so special.

Unlike abrasives that simply scrub at plaque, activated edathamil works at the molecular level to break down the protein biofilm that plaque bacteria cling to. This means it doesn’t just polish teeth and leave them cleaner - it helps stop plaque from sticking to your teeth in the first place.

Clinical research shows the formula can remove plaque 250% more effectively, while also improving gum health by 190% better. It could stop bleeding gums altogether in as little as 4 weeks of regular, consistent use. That’s a measurable difference most natural toothpastes can’t claim.

That’s not all, though. LIVFRESH also supports the tooth remineralization process, helping to fend off cavities and make your oral health more resilient in the long run. It works similarly to fluoride in this regard, but without the questionable surrounding context.

Another advantage lies in what you don’t get. LIVFRESH is free of fluoride, SLS, parabens, artificial sweeteners, and unnecessary foaming agents (in our foam-free version - we have a foaming toothpaste too, though).

You get that clean, fresh feel without the synthetic chemicals often linked to irritation. It’s also vegan, cruelty-free, and crafted with ingredient transparency at the forefront.

LIVFRESH comes in multiple mint-forward flavors that leave your mouth feeling smooth and polished, thanks to how the biofilm-removing technology reduces that “fuzzy teeth” feeling. It’s a great choice for anyone with mouth sensitivity.

It’s definitely not cheap at $34.99 per tube - but we spent $20 million creating this formula, and it shows in the results. Think about how much money you could save over the course of your life with fewer dental complications! LIVFRESH delivers incredible value for the money.

It’s the best toothpaste for receding gums and the best toothpaste to remove plaque and tartar all at once. You don’t just have to take our word for it, either. We’re endorsed by thousands of dentists and have 4,000+ five-star reviews from real people like you.

So, place your order with peace of mind knowing it’s backed by our satisfaction guarantee!

RiseWell Toothpaste

RiseWell has built its reputation around hydroxyapatite, a naturally occurring mineral that makes up about 97% of tooth enamel. It’s one of the most popular alternatives to Fluoride.

The RiseWell formula in particular uses a synthetic, non-nano version of hydroxyapatite as a fluoride replacement.

The goal is to strengthen enamel and reduce sensitivity at the same time. It also includes xylitol to fight cavity-causing bacteria and hydrated silica for gentle polishing.

RiseWell is often recommended for children as well as adults who want a more natural option because it’s marketed as safe to swallow. There’s no SLS, artificial flavors, or harsh foaming agents, either. So is this the best David’s toothpaste alternative? Not quite.

The thing is, hydroxyapatite is not universally recognized by U.S. dental associations as a proven substitute for fluoride. There are some studies looking at its remineralizing ability, but nothing quite to the extent of the clinical testing our patented formula has been put through.

RiseWell is still a decent option compared to the basic drug store brands when you want something fluoride-free, but it’s not on the same level as LIVFRESH.

Boka Toothpaste

Boka is another brand that leans heavily on nano-hydroxyapatite (n-Ha), a finer form of the mineral designed to penetrate microscopic enamel pores and reduce sensitivity.

The flagship toothpaste Boka makes is fluoride-free, SLS-free, and uses xylitol, aloe vera, and green tea extract to freshen breath while supporting the oral microbiome. That’s what sets Boka vs David’s toothpaste apart - the focus on creating the optimal conditions in your mouth.

You also get to choose from quite a few different flavors, but Ela Mint is the most popular. It’s a good candidate if you want something that’s pleasant to brush with and don’t want any synthetic sweeteners or artificial foaming agents in your oral care regimen.

People also love the smooth texture and the concept that it can remineralize your teeth without fluoride.

So what’s the catch? Boka falls short in the very same way RiseWell does. Hydroxyapatite may be promising, but it just doesn’t have nearly the same level of clinical evidence or professional endorsement as Activated Edathamil.

Plus, it’s not cheap at $14-$28 per tube. You’re paying a premium for something unproven. Is it a good toothpaste? Yes. Is it the best David’s toothpaste alternative? Not by a long shot.

Tom’s of Maine Toothpaste

Tom’s of Maine has been around for decades and is often one of the first “natural” brands people recognize - so it should come as no surprise the company’s toothpaste is considered a compelling alternative to David’s.

Their toothpastes vary wildly, though - which means you have no shortage of options. Some include fluoride, while others are fluoride-free. Common ingredients you’ll see on the label are calcium carbonate as a mild abrasive, xylitol for sweetness and cavity protection, and natural flavorings such as peppermint oil.

Tom’s avoids artificial preservatives, colors, and animal testing, which definitely earns it points with those who are focused on sustainability and clean living. That said, Tom’s can be hit-or-miss depending on the specific product.

The fluoride-free versions don’t offer the same level of cavity prevention as fluoride-based toothpastes - or those with n-Ha or Activated Edathamil. They’re just going to clean teeth, not do anything remarkable from a plaque removal or gum health perspective.

On the other hand, the options that do use fluoride may provide a little more tooth remineralization capabilities, but they’re essentially just a cleaner version of the basic drug store formulas.

We also read through quite a few reviews talking about how the toothpaste feels chalky and tastes less fresh than premium alternatives. It’s a bit lower on our list of alternatives to David’s toothpaste for all these reasons.

Hello Toothpaste

Hello has carved out a niche by marketing itself as a fun, friendly, and natural alternative that doesn’t take itself too seriously.

Their line is broad, ranging from fluoride and fluoride-free options to kids’ pastes and whitening formulas.

The brand’s most popular formula is its Antiplaque + Whitening Fluoride-Free Toothpaste, made with tea tree oil, coconut oil, xylitol, and farm-grown peppermint for freshness. There’s no SLS, parabens, triclosan, artificial dyes, or sweeteners. That’s all great.

We also think it’s worth mentioning you might be able to find this toothpaste in retail settings, if you’re in a rush and don’t want to purchase it online. That’s where the benefits end, though, and the drawbacks begin.

Hello toothpaste claims to fight plaque and support whitening, but we don’t see anything in the formula that supports this. It relies on mild abrasives and botanicals rather than clinically proven actives. Results vary for people with high cavity risk or gum concerns.

You can learn more about Tom’s vs Hello toothpaste if you want to see how these last two David’s toothpaste alternatives stack up to one another. But the key takeaway is this: nothing compares to LIVFRESH!

What to Look For in an Alternative to David’s Toothpaste

So which of these is the right David’s toothpaste alternative for you? It depends on what you’re looking for in a toothpaste! Is it cavity prevention, whitening, plaque removal, or gum health? Here are some things to consider as you weigh your options:

Active Ingredient Efficacy: Look closely at what the formula relies on - fluoride, hydroxyapatite, or something else entirely. Not all “clean” alternatives are backed by science, so you want ingredients with clinical data supporting real results.
Plaque Control and Gum Support: Whitening and flavor are nice, but if a toothpaste doesn’t reduce plaque buildup or support gum health, it’s falling short. Look for options that specifically target biofilm, the root of most dental problems.
Formula Transparency: Natural marketing is meaningless unless every ingredient earns its place. Choose an alternative with no unnecessary fillers, harsh foaming agents, or synthetic preservatives.
Safety for Daily Use: Consider whether the product is safe to swallow, works for kids as well as adults, and won’t create risks with long-term exposure. You need to enjoy brushing with the toothpaste, too - otherwise, you might not be consistent enough.
Value Beyond Price: Cheap toothpaste might save a few dollars but you’re not getting anything more than surface-level cleaning. The best option justifies its price with performance you can actually feel.

When you stack these factors together, LIVFRESH rises above the competition as the clear choice for your David’s toothpaste alternative. It’s backed by 26 clinical studies and recommended by thousands of dentists worldwide. Order now and experience the difference!

Parting Thoughts on Choosing a David’s Toothpaste Alternative

That does it for our David’s toothpaste alternative breakdown. While we can appreciate what this brand does bring to the table, your oral care regimen is not something you can afford to cut corners or compromise on.

From hydroxyapatite-based blends to traditional sensitivity relief, there’s no shortage of options. But nothing matches the proven performance of LIVFRESH when it comes to plaque removal/prevention, gum health improvements, and tooth remineralization.

Our blog has additional resources comparing brands like Boka vs RiseWell toothpaste or Sensodyne vs Parodontax if you want to explore even more options. At the end of the day, though, there’s no better upgrade for your oral health than our formula at LIVFRESH.